Wednesday, May 19, 2010

An article I found thought-provoking...

The article below is from a publication I get called the e-pistle from CMDA's (Christian Medicaland Dental Association) Center for Medical Missions. I enjoyed reading it and hope you do, too. Just some thoughts about how short-term and long-term missions can work together! And by the way, I did get permission from the author to post this. Enjoy!

A Cool Drink of Water
by Michael Soderling, MD

Short term health-related missions outreaches (STHRM) have exploded in number these past 30 years. Exact statistics are hard to come by, since the agencies which send out such teams vary so greatly. Some are sent by established agencies with a long track record of doing STHRM’s and some go out through their local church, while others go as a part of a medical school outreach. In any case, there are thousands of health care professionals who take part in STHRM’s each year. Much suffering is alleviated by these compassionate health care providers. But during a recent visit I had with a team working in Central America, I heard a very common refrain having to do with the nature of what some call “storm clinics”: coming into a poor community with a team of health care providers to do mostly primary health-type work. These efforts are often linked to some form of evangelism and even community health-related education.

The refrain I refer to is usually in response to a question I always pose: what long term impact will the team have on the health of the people they seek to serve? The refrain goes something like this: “We know what we are doing will likely not have a long term impact on the health of the people, but what we are doing is like giving the people a cool drink of water in the desert.” The other explanation I often hear is this: “We know what we are doing isn’t addressing the deeper needs of the community and those who live here, but we are at least able to put a band-aid on the problem that will help in some small way.”

I have used this reasoning myself when explaining my previous involvement with such teams. But after this most recent encounter, I had to ask myself if this rationale is valid. Would Jesus have given someone He encountered in the desert a cool drink of water and then walked away leaving the person still in the desert? What came to mind immediately was the parable of the Good Samaritan.

Let's examine briefly this parable in Luke 10. We read in the 10th chapter of Luke that a man falls prey to robbers who strip and beat him to within an inch of his life and leave him for dead. Anyone who has done cross-cultural ministry in the majority world can probably relate to the scene as it unfolds. The religious authorities pass by, not being allowed to help because of the rigidity of their traditions. I think it is very much like what we find in many cultures around the world. The poor may not be literally beaten by the non-poor, but the systems that are in place and which maintain the status quo give the poor the same feeling as if they were physically beaten and left for dead. This is the background into which many of our medical teams are parachuted, with the hope of doing as much as they can in a limited amount of time.

But along comes the Good Samaritan, right? He sees the crumpled figure on the side of the road looking little better than road kill. I imagine that Roman chariots produced a bit of that back in those days. The chariot race scene in Ben Hur comes to mind. The Good Samaritan has a huge heart and stops to help. Luke relates the scene to us in verse 34a: "When he saw him, he was moved with compassion, came to him, and bound up his wounds, pouring on oil and wine." Now, doesn't that describe what so many are about when it comes to STMM's? Compassion. Healing. Ministering to the suffering. How many of us have looked into the eyes of the hopeless and physically beaten down, whom God loves with all His heart, and felt moved to action? And for many health-related professionals, this takes the form of a short term, maybe one or two week, medical mission trip. But how many of us, myself included, have felt at the end of the trip that what we did was somehow so inadequ! ate? Then comes that reassurance that what we did was like offering someone suffering in the desert a cool drink of water.

But let's return to our parable. Does it end with the Good Samaritan treating the wounds and maybe giving a drink of water and then leaving the man at the side of the road (still in the desert)? Let's read the text from 34b through 35; “He set him on his own animal, and brought him to an inn, and took care of him. On the next day, when he departed, he took out two denarii, and gave them to the host, and said to him, ‘Take care of him. Whatever you spend beyond that, I will repay you when I return.’"

First we see our good friend the Samaritan putting this weak and still suffering individual on his own animal in order to take him to an inn for further care. And he didn't just drop him on the doorstep to let the innkeeper deal with the situation. He stayed with the man all night while continually caring for the man's wounds and tending to his other needs. How many times have we found ourselves with very difficult medical challenges, such as a patient with a blood sugar of 400, during a STMM trip, with no knowledge of what to do for them? Many groups I have seen work with no local healthcare providers and have no plan for follow-up of difficult patients, because they have not taken the time to develop the necessary relationships in the communities in which they are going to work. It's just short term after all. Who has the time or resources to do that kind of partnership development?

After caring for this person all night, the Good Samaritan pays for the man to be cared for by the innkeeper. Now, I don't know to what level innkeepers were trained in caring for injured travelers, but maybe it was more than we would imagine. After all, in the early history of the West in the US, it was the barbers who often worked as doctors, as I recall. In any case, he made plans for long term follow-up. And whatever needs came up, he would pay the innkeeper accordingly UPON HIS RETURN!!

This makes a good case, I believe, for not thinking only with a short term mentality concerning our STHRM's. There is much power in the "both/and" approach, as Jim Collins has written about in his book, Built to Last. Why does it have to be that one is involved either in short term work or long term initiatives? Can you imagine the results we would see if we took a coordinated approach to our work in the health-related fields of ministry? And I am not speaking only of how Christian health-related ministries could more effectively work together. I am also urging a greater coordination with local governmental and non-governmental agencies that may not have a spiritual basis for their work. I know there are those who are actively involved in these kinds of efforts already, and I applaud these efforts. But many, probably the majority, are not doing so and should carefully assess what they are getting into. I believe that if we are to truly see our vast resources used to effe! ctively improve the health of the poor around the world while also strengthening the local church, it must be the health care professionals who are being asked to help in these efforts (with their time, talents and treasures) who begin to ask important questions about the nature and conduct of such short term health-related missions.

Let's pretend for a moment we are that Good Samaritan. Our group of highly trained healthcare professionals does a fantastic job of caring for the man's wounds with the basic meds that were acquired in-country, based on the WHO recommendations for developing nations. Because our team took the time to partner with the local church and a local Christian health worker, we are aware that there is no nearby Christian clinic or hospital which can care for this person's ongoing needs. But there is a local government-run hospital, though it is chronically short of most basic medications. But the bed is available, and because our local contacts have an ongoing relationship with the director of the hospital, we are able to secure a bed and nursing care. We invite the local hospital administrator to share dinner with us to further build our relationship for the future and to find out about the needs of the hospital he serves. Also attending the dinner are the local mayor and some of! the people who are part of the local community development committee. We find out more about the community and its desperate need for a clean water supply. Someone on our team has a contact in his local Rotary Club back home who is interested in doing a water project for a poor community in a developing nation. The local pastor has always wanted to develop a hospital ministry outreach, and a nurse on the team has access to teaching materials that will help him achieve this goal. The list of ideas could go on and on. For example, after finding out about the chronic shortages at the hospital, the team decides to donate the medications that remain at the end of the week to the hospital and its outpatient clinic. This of course would best be done in the presence of many witnesses.

Well, you see then where this beautiful parable has taken us. It would certainly not be a parable Jesus would have turned to if it had ended with the Good Samaritan simply tending to the man's wounds but leaving him at the side of the road (in the desert, as it were). No. The power of the parable lies as much in what the Good Samaritan did after meeting the most immediate need. He helped meet the longer-term needs as well.

In the 2010 Winter Olympics, the bronze medal in the 1500 m short track skating event went to J.R. Celski of the United States. Celski injured his right leg when he crashed during the final race of Olympic trials on Sept. 12 in Marquette, Michigan, five months to the day from the 2010 Olympics Opening Ceremony. Celski's left skate blade punctured his right thigh, slicing completely through his quadriceps muscle. He had to pull the skate blade from his leg as blood poured onto the ice. It left a 6-inch-wide gash. Fortunately for him, he received quick professional medical attention that included something more than just a band-aid. J.R. Celski’s life represents the lives and communities of many living in the majority world. We, the Church of Christ on this earth, have the necessary resources to meet these needs. But we will continue to see these needs go unmet if we do not begin to ask of the agencies with which we work, be they our local church or a well-established missi! on agency, how the work we do is going to have long-term impact on the health of the people. We can no longer be content with merely giving a cool drink of water in the desert.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Thinking about Liberia today

For the past week or so for some reason I've had Liberia on my mind even more frequently than usual. Usually a couple times a day I think about my friends in Liberia, but often it's the thoughts of wondering how they are doing, what they are up to, and reading their status/interacting with them on Facebook. But especially this past Thursday and today, I have been thinking more along the lines of itching to go back, or at least thinking about the dreams I have to go back, and what kind of things I would be doing. I'm not sure what exactly prompted it - it could just be the fact that it's now been 10 months that I've been back in the US this time, and as a typical TCK (third culture kid), that means it's about time to be thinking of "what's next."

The thing is, I already have "what's next" kind of planned out, and I expect that to be staying in the US for another couple years while I pursue my master's degree. But then after that? I look forward to the possibility of heading back and spending my time in a capacity of helping educate health professionals. But right now that seems a long way in the future, so I think about what I can do now to prepare, and I wonder how much will change in the intervening time to change how my dreams will look. That's what was really going through my mind on Thursday.

Today's thoughts were less about my dreams, and more about the "big picture" in Liberia, and wondering (once again) what the answer is for mission organizations and faith-based NGOs (non-government organizations) - how and when will we see change - changed lives and changed hearts? You see, when I think about how many expats are received in Liberia, it is with the expectation that we will improve the quality of life/economic status of those we come in contact with. And while that's definitely something that I am interested in doing, it's not my goal at all. It's changed hearts and changed lives, people with a true knowledge of Christ as their Savior. How do all the activities that we busy ourselves with accomplish this? How will doing the things I dream of doing accomplish this? And how can I make sure to keep this the focus rather than accomplishing tasks?

I think these are questions that all missionaries and Christian development workers struggle with at various times. I know I have struggled with them in the past, and will probably continue to have to munch on these thoughts many more times in the future. I'm not sure we will have answers - so my prayer today is that God will use His servants who are there working now to shine His light today, to encourage them and give them the energy and patience to deal with the many tangible "priority" problems that they face each day and to go beyond their tasks to share Christ through their words and their lives.